Bob Anderson as an Army Back

Army’s Guided Missile

Coach Earl BlaikBy Kevin Hynes

“Tim Cohane, LOOK Magazines Sports Editor, says Army’s Bob Anderson is the finest sophomore to hit the collegiate football horizon since Red Grange ran wild in his first year at Illinois”. — Los Angeles Times, Sports Editor Paul Zimmerman’s column, November 20, 1957.

“Bob Anderson is the greatest player West Point has had since Glenn Davis.” –Earl Blaik to Stanley Woodward, Editor, Dell Magazine Football Preview, August, 1959

The consensus preseason favorite for the 1959 Heisman Trophy, judging from the contemporary reportage, was Army halfback Bob Anderson. The competition was very formidable. LSU halfback Billy Cannon possessed an unprecedented blend of power (208 pounds) and 9.5 speed, while the charismatic SMU QB, Don Meredith, was merely the most accurate passer college football had ever seen. But Anderson was expected to become the first three-time All-American back since Doak Walker and thus join a very exclusive club otherwise consisting of (modern era) Doc Blanchard, Glenn Davis, Chris Cagle and Red Grange.

While this great player has seemingly been forgotten for years, at last he is being recognized again as he has been elected to the College Football Hall of Fame with the class of 2004. As well see, he was quite possibly the nation’s dominant offensive force in his spectacular 1957 debut And while overshadowed in 1958 by the big play brilliance of teammate Pete Dawkins, the Heisman Trophy winner, Coach Earl “Red” Blaik insisted that Anderson was even more valuable than he’d been the year before.

Army produced 14 All Americans between 1947 and Blaik’s retirement in 1958, and others made their AA mark elsewhere after transferring in the wake of the 1951 cribbing scandals. “Lonely End” Bill Carpenter, Anderson’s classmate, joined this roster in 1959. Carpenter, incidentally, has been in the College Football Hall of Fame since 1982; Pete Dawkins since 1975. Don Holleder (Army 1953-55) was inducted in 1985. None of them started as sophomores, simply because Blaik just didn’t believe in playing a “yearling” unless someone really extraordinary came along.

Bob Anderson, New Jersey-born on March 31,1938, won 15 letters in four sports at Cocoa, Florida H.S., and, unlike most West Point football players, was a widely sought after blue chipper who nearly went to powerhouse Georgia Tech. In his plebe year he played football and basketball and was the leading hitter for the baseball team. When he joined the Army football varsity in 1957 the Black Knights were coming off a 5-3-1 season and Blaik was concerned about his defense, depth (a perennial problem) and an inexperienced line. The quarterback position, a thorn in the Cadets’ side since Pete Vann’s graduation, at least had an experienced operative in Dave Bourland but passing would be largely avoided The Cadets ran out of a tight “T” and their game was speed.

During spring training Blaik and his staff immediately saw the potential in two untried halfbacks. This is Blaik’s introduction of Anderson in his autobiography (1960): “Anderson, 19, six feet 2, 205, from Cocoa, Florida, was the best all-around football player at the Academy since Blanchard and Davis. While his classic naturalness in every phase of play delighted the connoisseur, Anderson was most exciting as a runner. He had power that blasted through and over tacklers, speed that could outstay pursuit, and a flavor of king-size niftiness… He did everything well, running, blocking, tackling, passing, catching passes, defending against them, punting. He was also one of the most self effacing and selfless team players I ever encountered.”

Joining Anderson at right half would be Pete Dawkins, a non-lettering junior who was making a successful switch from quarterback A relatively late bloomer athletically, still more known for his astounding off the field record in the classroom and as a student leader, he nevertheless was rapidly adding size (six foot one, 195 pounds) and speed. While never the blocker or defender that Anderson was, he demonstrated rare talent as a runner and receiver.

The 1957 season opened with a visit by Nebraska. These were the doldrum years for the Cornhuskers (1-9) and they gave little opposition to Army, which raced to a 28-0 halftime lead. The Associated Press reporter noted that “Bob Anderson, a 200 pound sophomore speedster, looked particularly impressive.” It took him just two minutes to score the Cadets’ first touchdown of the year, a four yard run set up by his 27-yard burst. Reserves built the final score to 42-0 as Army ran off a mind-boggling 89 plays.

The next week a record Penn State crowd of 32,660 rooted for a first-ever victory by their Nittany Lions (6-3) over the Cadets but Army scored on third quarter TD marches of 71, 66 and 40 yards to win 27-13. Anderson had tied the game with a second period TD, but again sat out most of the second half, this time with an injury. Dave Bourland was the game’s standout performer with his ball handling, running, and some timely passing.

It was here that Anderson took off: in the next six games alone he rushed for 837 yards; a top five figure for that entire season.

The explosion was against Notre Dame in the most publicized regular season game in years: the schools hadn’t met since 1947 when (Weyand) “the sports world was shaken by an announcement that the most famous athletic event of all time, the Army-Notre Dame series, would be discontinued.” Philadelphia’s huge Memorial Stadium would host the first rematch in a decade between two powerful teams whose respective programs were clearly back on the rise. The

unbeaten and un-scored upon Irish were big, fast and deep with three All Americans-to-be (GuardAl Ecuyer, fullback Nick Pietrosante, end Monte Stickles,) plus future pros like Bronco Nagurski Jr., Dick Lynch and soph QB George Izo (second pick in the ’59 NFL draft) who backed up allstar candidate Bob Williams. The Irish would later crush SMU 54-21 and USC 40-12, and most importantly, snap the Oklahoma Sooners 47-game winning streak, 7-0, in Norman.

The game drew 95,000 fans and was televised nationally. Amazingly, it surpassed expectations.From the AP’s breathless report: “The viewers were treated to a staccato succession of thrills which shaded even the memories of Chris Cagle, Doc Blanchard and Glenn Davis of Army and the fabled Four Horsemen of Notre Dame. Bob Anderson, a long legged 19 year old, lit the fuse in the opening 3 minutes of play with an 81 yard TD run on a pitchout. The fleet halfback constantly was ripping off long gains and catching passes to confuse the Notre Dame defense.”On the described play, Army’s second from scrimmage, Anderson broke a tackle inside right end,cut back sharply, then eluded the safety with a crossover step that left the defender literally sitting on the ground; an “ankle breaker.” From there he easily outran future All-Pro Dick Lynch to score the longest run from scrimmage in the history of the storied series.

Notre Dame managed to tie the game before the half on a Pietrosante plunge that capped an 80

PAGE 14yard drive. The third quarter saw Army go up 21-7 on 72 and 81 yard scoring marches, includingAnderson’s second TD. But in the fourth quarter Pietrosante broke free from a pileup at the scrimmage line for a 65-yard TD. Notre Dame then cut the margin to 21-20 with a 56-yard drive with Lynch carrying the last seven plays, all behind Ecuyer. Stickles was temporarily the goat after his PAT miss. But when an Army screen pass was deflected and dropped straight into the arms of Pietrosante, who was sprawled on his back after being soundly blocked, the Irish were in luck. Stickles’ 23-yard field goal won the game, 23-21.

Earl Blaik called this defeat “the hardest I had to take in 25 years as a head coach,” yet Army,which out gained Notre Dame 386-335, moved up to #8 in the polls. And Bob Anderson was propelled into the national limelight; he really wasn’t stopped all day, finishing with 186 yard srushing on 15 carries and well over 200 all purpose yards.

Next was a typically rugged Pittsburgh squad that many felt played the toughest schedule in the country. They’d lost their opener to Oklahoma– no disgrace there — but were now 3-1, with wins over USC and Nebraska (34-0). Anderson and Pitt passing ace Ivan Toncic traded touchdowns in the first half. The game turned on a 17-play (16 runs)83-yard march, which Anderson (20 carries for 96yards) capped with another score. Then he made two fourth quarter interceptions to set up a touchdown and a field goal as Army pulled away to win 29-13. Afterwards the “usually taciturn” Blaik told The Sporting News, “Anderson is the best sophomore back I’ve seen since Glenn Davis.”Stanley Woodward would add, “the Colonel is no man to rate a football player merely on his ability as a runner.”

The next week the Cadets were two touchdown favorites over what proved to be a 3-6-1 Virginia squad. But the game was played in Charlottesville and the Cavaliers had some weapons, especially All-
BOB ANDERSON American fullback Jim Bahktaier (a top-10 rusher nationally all three seasons) and 9.6 halfback speedster Ulmo “Sonny” Randle. Indeed, the Cadets

found their hands very full. Anderson scored early in the game on a short run, but the Cadets were trailing 12-7 as the fourth quarter began. At this point, (AP): “Army hitched its offense to the flying feet of Bob Anderson” as they marched 94 yards for the winning score. He completed the drive with a 16-yard TD catch from Bourland, who then hooked up with Dawkins in the final minute for a 20-12 victory. Anderson ran for 100 yards as the Cadets held a narrow 319-296margin in total offense.

The next contest, versus Colgate (3-6), was mostly notable for the attendance of the former WestPoint halfback, President Dwight Eisenhower. The long series had produced an amazing 55-48Army triumph in 1956 (Princess Grace and Prince Ranier viewed that one), but this year’s game was a mismatch. Anderson only carried eight times as Blaik went to the bench early, yet still picked up 96 yards and added two more scores. Despite numerous fumbles the Cadets converted578 yards and 31 first downs into a 53-7 victory.

Then Utah visited Michie Stadium. The colorful Redskins threw out of a pro-set featuring Lee

Grosscup, who had broken several of the fabled Ronnie Knox’s passing records as a prep All-
American in Santa Monica, CA. A college All American this year (thanks in no small part to this contest) he entered the game having completed 72% of his passes as the high scoring Utes (6-4)would eventually win the national passing title. The game promised to be one of the Cadets most exciting of the year. That it was is something of an understatement.

From the AP headline: “Lee Grosscup, Utah’s amazing passer from Santa Monica, CA, befuddled the Army defense today but Bob Anderson’s superb running and Army’s all around strength proved a bit too much for the Redskins… Anderson, Army’s elusive sophomore, scored three touchdowns and threw a great running pass for a fourth.”

Army took an early 14-0 lead behind two Anderson touchdowns, but Utah roared back with long returns and through the air. At 13:36 of the third quarter, with Army ahead 20-14, Anderson broke through the right side of the Utah line, sidestepped two tacklers and outran halfback Don McGivney to the goal line on a “thrilling” 54-yard dash.

After Utah immediately cut the margin to 26-20, Army drove 65 yards on eight plays behind Dawkins (80 yards on 13 carries) and Anderson, whose seven-yard, off-balance TD throw to Bill Graff raised the score to 33-20. Utah answered with a three play TD march featuring a 53-yardpass play. By now the crowd was delirious, but “with Anderson in charge” Army marched 72yards on 12 plays to take a 39-27 lead with one minute of play remaining. Which was enough time for Grosscup to hit all-time NFL great Larry Wilson with another scoring toss as the gun went off. Final score: 39-33.

Anderson had rushed for 214 yards on 30 carries and accounted for four touchdowns. Grosscup finished up 14 for 26 for 316 yards and two TD passes. In a post-season AP writers poll this contest was voted the second best of the 1957 season, trailing only the Notre Dame-Oklahoma shocker, with Anderson and Grosscup splitting votes for the outstanding performance.

Few felt that the Black Knights would be tested by their next foe, a 2-8 Tulane team, even traveling to New Orleans. But, as in the road trip to Virginia, the Cadets had to play catchup.Again, the AP lead: “Bob Anderson, the nation’s leading scorer, led Army to a 20-14 come-from behind victory over underdog Tulane, as the 200 pound sophomore broke Glenn Davis’ record for rushing yardage with 145 yards to boost his season total to 965.”

The game was nip and tuck all the way as the Army passing game fell completely apart (1 for12). The Green Wave held a 14-13 lead in the fourth quarter following a 61-yard run by BooMason (Tommy’s older brother) and a 66-yard punt return from QB Richie Pettibon. With less than five minutes remaining Army faced fourth and two at their own 26. Here, said Blaik, there commenced “the greatest display” he ever saw at Army. “They (Anderson and Dawkins) went 74yards on their own strength, with the team losing, the line crumbling and time running out.” It was mostly Anderson; he got the clutch call and fought ten yards over guard. Dawkins went 21through traffic on a reverse. Then it was Anderson off-tackle for 30, FB Vic Barta for three, andAnderson sweeping end for the final ten yards, his 14th touchdown of the year. At the game’s end Anderson (NY Times) “leaped high to bat down a Tulane pass in the end zone,” deflecting the ball into Dawkins’ hands for the touchback. Army was now 7-1

Dawkins, entering with 437 yards, had carried 26 for 165 (career highs), so the halfbacks combined for 310 yards. They’d scored 25 of the Cadets 37 touchdowns and Anderson’s 965 yard,142 carry count was two yards shy of NCAA leader Leon Burton of Arizona State. (BorderConference members provided eight rushing champs between 1954 and 1962.)

Following the traditional bye and preparation week, it was a return to Memorial Stadium — and a crowd of 101,000 rain drenched fans — to meet Navy, ranked #7 with a 7-1-1 record thus far.The Middies featured an extremely mobile line and two All Americans, quarterback Tom Forrestal and big junior tackle-linebacker Bob Reif snyder. They also would have back the services of their captain, HB Ned Oldham, a versatile three-year standout who’d been injured fora month.

Army led the nation in rushing and ranked second in scoring and total offense. Navy was second in total defense. Something would have to give — it turned out to be Anderson’s knee, followed by the Army attack. He’d been withheld from contact drills to protect the already “severely strained” knee. Now, on the first play, it was re-injured. Moreover, Navy unveiled a new gap defense, with linemen and linebackers jumping in and out of the line right up to the snap. The pass was virtually ignored. Army was limited to seven first downs (to Navy’s 15) and out gained 237 to 136. Dawkins took over the main rushing chores, picking up 63 of the team’s 88 yards in17 carries. From Blaik: “Anderson was held to 18 yards on 11 carries. Dawkins felt the pressure of his first Navy game as a regular and mussed up several assignments, one of them causing a fumble on their nine, after a 60 yard drive with Dawkins doing most of the gaining, helped byAnderson’s heavy blocking.” Ned Oldham stole the show, scoring all the points in a 14-0 win.The Midshipmen later routed Rice 20-7 in the Cotton Bowl.

Despite the disappointing finale, Anderson had produced an extraordinary season. His 983 yards ranked third nationally and would be surpassed only once more this decade. Ahead of him in 1957were the 9.5 sprinter Burton (1,126 plus 16 TDs to top scoring) and Colorado’s Single Wingtail back Bob Stransky (183 carries for 1,097), both 10 game performers. Army, of course, played a nine game schedule.

Anderson joined Illinois’ J.C. Caroline (1953) as the only consensus sophomore All-Americans since Doak Walker (1947). There wouldn’t be another first-year back chosen until freshman Tony Dorsett broke through in 1973. Caroline slumped as a junior before flunking out and playing the1955 season in Canada, and he’s been in the College Football Hall of Fame since 1980. 1950’s non-
consensus choice, Bobby Reynolds, whose Nebraska career was essentially ruined by injuries after a stunning debut, was inducted in 1984. Yet ahead for Bob Anderson, Pete Dawkins, and the rest of the Cadets was the 1958 season, the year of “The Lonely End.”

ArmyFB_1957_Anderson_OcalaStarBanner_Nov81957

ArmyFB_1957_BobAnderson_byAlanMaver_WashingtonObserver_Nov301957

ArmyFB_1958_BobAnderson_byPap_CorsicanaDailySun_Nov151958

ArmyFB_1958_Anderson_ArthurDaley_NYT_Dec11958

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s